On January 13, 1928, he went 10
rounds with lightweight champion and Hall of Famer Sammy Mandell
in a no-decision, non-title bout. Later that year he first drew
with Hall of Famer Jackie "Kid' Berg before scoring a 5th round
TKO in the rematch. In late 1930, Petrolle hit his stride,
decisioning Hall of Famers Tony Canzoneri and Jimmy McLarnin
within 2 months of each other. In 1932, he won back to back
bouts with Battling Battalino. On November 4, 1932 he lost a
15-round lightweight title match to Tony Canzoneri in the only
championship fight of his career. Following a loss to Barney
Ross in 1934, he retired from the ring.
In each of his bouts, (credited at
160 bouts, but strongly believed to be over 250), he entered the
ring with a red and green Navajo blanket as a good luck charm.
During his career he fought ten current or past world champions
and was victorious against five of them.
In retirement Petrolle ran a foundry
and later owned and operated a religious goods shop. Petrolle
died on May 14, 1983 in Vero Beach, FL.