Exactly sixty years ago, in the early summer of 1937,
Michiganians took great pride in the outcome of a fight in
Chicago. Joe Louis, the "Brown Bomber from Detroit," captured
the heavyweight boxing crown by knocking out James Braddock in
eight rounds.
Louis had quick reflexes and a
strong punch. Some experts think he was the best heavyweight
ever. In the twelve years after he beat the stuffing out of
Braddock, Louis defeated 24 challengers, 22 by knockout. His
hardest fight, however, was not with Max Schmeling or Rocky
Marciano, but with the Internal Revenue Service.
In 1914, the year Joe Louis was
born, the income tax had only been in place one year. The top
rate was a mere 7 percent, and a high exemption kept most
Americans off the tax rolls altogether. Even by 1931, the year
Joe Louis began boxing seriously, the income tax was so minimal
that only 2 percent of Americans even qualified to pay it.
When he earned over $371,000 in his
first two years as a professional boxer, Louis immediately
helped family and friends all over the country. For example, he
voluntarily paid back to the government welfare payments his
stepfather had received during the Great Depression. Later, he
supplied a house for an elderly Indian on property he owned. He
also bought needed uniforms for a group of black army officers.
Louis wanted private citizens to
solve many of the problems that Americans were increasingly
turning to government to solve. He opposed many of President
Franklin Roosevelt’s New Deal programs and campaigned for
Republican candidate Wendell Willkie for president in 1940.
Before the election, Louis sent Willkie this telegram: "Win by a
knockout. It will mean freedom from the WPA and for American
Negro rights." Meanwhile, tax rates from the ever growing
government that Louis opposed were heading toward the
stratosphere.
One month after the bombing of Pearl
Harbor, the generous Louis gave his entire $65,200 fee (about
$700,000 in today’s money) from a fight to the Naval Relief
Fund. Less than three months later, he gave his $45,882 purse
from another fight (about $500,000 today) to the Army Relief
Fund. Ever the patriot, he halted his lucrative boxing career
and enlisted as a private, earning only $21 a month.
When the war ended, Louis hoped to
retire from boxing with savings in the bank and dignity from his
career. He lost both. What he overlooked was the enlarged role
of government and the taxes he owed to help keep it growing.
Under President Roosevelt, the tax base had expanded to where
most American families (not the mere 2 percent of a few years
before) had to pay income taxes. Worse for Joe Louis was the
steep tax levied on high incomes. From 1931, his first year in
boxing, to 1937, when he knocked out Braddock, the top marginal
tax rate had soared from 24 to 79 percent. Louis found himself
owing the government most of his purse money from each of his
fights.
During the 1940s, the top marginal
rate was hiked to 90 percent, and Joe Louis found himself over
$500,000 in debt to the IRS in back taxes. Roosevelt’s new tax
laws were complicated and Louis, unlike later successful
athletes, had no tax shelters, municipal bonds, or clever
accountants. The IRS would not let him deduct the two fight
purses he had donated to the army and navy. He couldn’t even
deduct $3,000 worth of tickets that he had bought for soldiers
to one of those fights. What’s more, the interest payments were
compounded each year, ballooning his debt into seven figures
during the 1950s.
Louis retired in 1949, undefeated as
a champion, but now he had to fight again. "I had to keep
working to pay taxes," Louis said, "but the more I worked, the
less I had."
In 1950, Louis "announced that I’d
decided to come out of retirement and challenge Ezzard Charles
for the championship. The reason—taxes." Louis lost the match in
a 15-round decision. After the fight, when Louis called his
mother, she "begged me to stop now, but she couldn’t understand
how much money I owed . . . . The government wanted their money
and I had to try to get it to them."
The next year, for a $300,000 purse,
the 37-year-old Louis fought Rocky Marciano, but was knocked out
in the eighth round. Technically, he owed the whole purse to the
IRS, but since he had to pay a 90 percent tax rate on most of
his earnings, plus back interest from previous years, he still
could not whittle down his debt. Louis’s boxing career was over,
and he would never be able to earn the money to satisfy the tax
collectors. He died in debt, a broken man. Were he with us
today, he might well be one of America’s foremost champions of
replacing the current system with a low, flat tax.
Joe Louis would want to be
remembered as a champion, a patriot, and a role model for
children. He admitted that he overlooked the new tax laws, that
he trusted too many friends, and that he spent money unwisely.
As we think about his life, we should remember Joe Louis as an
expert in the use of physical force to knock out his boxing
adversaries, but as a novice when government used political
force to knock him out.